 |
Click here to remove search term highlighting
SHELTER HARMER ARCHITECTURE’S LATEST MAUSOLEUM IS A SMALL, SUBTLE SHELTER ON THE EDGE OF MILDURA.
REVIEW GRAHAM CRIST PHOTOGRAPHY TREVOR MEIN
| Review |
|
The mausoleum seen across the manicured lawn
of Murray Pines Cemetery.
|
Detail of the waving
steel screen enclosure.
|
The articulated meeting of
roof, crypt and screen.
|
The figured green marble
faces of the caskets, with the landscape beyond visible
through the screens.
|
The solid forms of the mausoleum seen across the
the landscape preservation area.
|
Internal view.
|
|
|
class="highlighttext">HARMER ARCHITECTURE HAS completed a new mausoleum for the Murray
Pines Cemetery in Mildura, Victoria, a building which will house 100 of Mildura’s dead.
Located on the edge of the town near the airport, the mausoleum is, like Mildura itself, a
settled moment on the edge of the desert. Enclosed only by a fence, and containing one
room, it is barely a building at all. The mausoleum is an architecturally difficult type here
as it has little local precedent, and this site is also a difficult one – a place where such a
building seems particularly unlikely. The value of this project is that it overcomes such
difficulties, and avoids some cliches, to produce some real architectural presence.
The garden cemetery is such a dominant form in this country that it has been
almost uncontested as a type in two hundred years of white burials. In fact, it is only in
the last ten years that legislation has permitted mausolea here at all. (A measure of this
rarity is the fact that the contractors were an American firm with relevant expertise.) New
enough in the Melbourne suburbs, mausolea are perhaps even more unusual on a site
with virtually no other buildings visible. At Murray Pines, the building is approached from
a road through garden plots and headstones laid out in rows on the ground – a new site
with no burials more than about five years old. Inside, four blocks each contain twentyfive
caskets – five rows each sacked five high. The caskets are faced in highly figured
green marble and each has a small gold anodized vase fixed to it. It is expected that the
Italian community of Mildura will be its main purchasers – they get a place which is off
the ground and part of a monument which is greater than any individual plot. The
mausoleum stands as both a monument and a garden pavilion – a roof over an open
space that faces a garden – in the tradition of special pavilions.
Mies van der Rohe’s German Pavilion at Barcelona springs to mind for comparison.
Not because this building is an essay on that project, but, superficially, for the dominant
green polished marble, and also for the sense of partial enclosure. The palette of
materials is also clearly articulated as planes. The crypt faces of marble, the sandstone
floor, the plywood ceiling, concrete outer walls, and the steel columns are all clearly
separated; there is no folding or blending between them. Of course, the differences
between the two buildings are equally pronounced. In Mildura, Barcelona’s chrome
columns become a grille of galvanized flats, dispersed and carry a waving line, and the
travertine plinth has flattened to a floor plan, rusticated in a crazy-paved sandstone. At
the same time, the roof is lifted off the walls, stretching the space vertically to about 4.5
metres. The horizontal trajectory between spaces and the glazed reflections of the Mies
pavilion is replaced by something pointed upward and out to the sky. The effect is
reversed, pushed into the ground and up into the sky and here, it seems just right.
It is often tempting for Australian architects to try to respond directly to the
aesthetic of the landscape. It is a beautiful landscape here: red earth and small, delicate
grey-green eucalypts. Not unique, but the kind of landscape which could stretch on
everywhere. The mausoleum negotiates between this and the garden, and an idea of the
urban, and manages to do so successfully. Rather than being like the bush, the building is
simply figured after it, a leaf in plan. This gesture is only really evident after seeing the
masterplan with a series repeated along branches, a giant garden with six big leaves –
an organic city of six hundred.
This first mausoleum faces the edge of the landscape preservation area (the
indigenous landscape is now protected) forming the junction between it and the start of
the clipped garden. Entry is via a little-made path on the neat lawn to a gate – domestic
in the suburban sense. As you face the marble, which is domestic in a grand sense, the
bush appears through three gaps. It completes the wall, its light enters these gaps from
the north and its wind blows through it. The bush is utterly unlike the solid blocks housing
the hundred crypts, but its constant appearance is the key to the space. The solid blocks
turn their back on the landscape, touching the earth as heavily as they need to.
The experience of an architecture like this involves some serious consideration of
mortality. The architect both forces some confrontation, and allows some comfort. At
Aldo Rossi’s necropolis in Modena we are confronted with a mass grave. In it, we are all
the same, and it is the same mass grave we have been thrown into for centuries, and
which seems to have no end. The comfort, paradoxically, lies in the constancy of this, in
its inevitability, its collectivity.
At Mildura, one is contained in a more finite space, one shaped around a room,
lined in rich materials. It feels like it might be a home. What we are confronted with
though, is the thinness of the room, the absence of its skin and the insignificance of the
situation. For all its apparent solidity, we can see the marble at its fine edge, hung on the
concrete. For all its mass, it does not enclose us; it does not separate us from the desert.
I was there when a cool breeze was blowing, and the room provided only partial shelter.
The room is so barely a room: the arc of the steel grill shifts from being virtually solid to
almost nothing; the sandstone is more a ground than a floor, conceptually a mere
shadow of the roof. Around the solid crypts we a reminded always of what is outside
them, as much as what is inside. There is an emptiness in all that which we need to
reconcile. In the building, we are protected just enough, but not too much. Flying out
of the town, the pavilion appears seems quite insignificant on the ground and then
quickly disappears.
The strength of this work, and its interest lies in its translation from Harmer’s
previous mausoleum design at the Faulkner Cemetery in Melbourne. The reduction in
scale and the removal of interior enclosure have produced something quite different.
While it doesn’t make excessive claims for itself, it engages in a subtle debate about
shelter. The client seems to appreciate this. I look forward to five more.
GRAHAM CRIST IS A PARTNER IN THE MELBOURNE PRACTICE S-ARCHITECTURE AND A LECTURER IN ARCHITECTURE AT RMIT UNIVERSITY.
|
| Project Credits |
MAUSOLEUM, MURRAY PINES CEMETERY
Architect Harmer Architecture—project architect Andrew
Briant; design team Philip Harmer, Andrew Briant, Grant
Dixon, Merran Bent. Structural and Civil Consultants GHD
Engineering. Builder Keith Miller & Sons in association with
Milne Construction Australia. Client Mildura Cemetery Trust.
|
|
